Perception vs. Reality: - AutoSuccessOnline

Perception vs. Reality:

There’s an old saying that a customer’s perception is the reality. Very seldom do I speak with a general manager or fixed operations director where the topic of competing against Jiffy Lube and Pep Boys does not come up. After the warranty expires, 70% of those aftermarket dollars are flowing right into everyone else’s hands. The possibilities are endless in this $350 billion market where by most accounts, franchise dealerships will get about 30% of that number.

Effective Strategies to Overcome the False Narrative About Franchise Dealerships

There’s an old saying that a customer’s perception is the reality. Very seldom do I speak with a general manager or fixed operations director where the topic of competing against Jiffy Lube and Pep Boys does not come up. After the warranty expires, 70% of those aftermarket dollars are flowing right into everyone else’s hands. The possibilities are endless in this $350 billion market where by most accounts, franchise dealerships will get about 30% of that number.

Independent repair facilities’ (IRF) “value proposition” is that they are far better priced than the local franchise dealership. That narrative has been created and well established in the minds of consumers. It has gone so far as that now IRFs are advertising their services on par with franchise dealerships, but not at their pricing. See a sample IRF ad in Figure 1.

Why does this narrative exist? Every partnership in life, albeit friendship, marriage or business relationships exists via a two-way street. Cooperation between the two parties can result in the best results. Why do I bring this up as it relates to the narrative regarding the price for IRFs implicit in helping this narrative as the independents who advertise it?   

Franchise dealerships for the longest time have neglected to have clear and transparent pricing on their websites. On the majority of the dealers I audit, the advertised price is a $5 off coupon. $5 off what?

The played-out narrative coupled with the fact franchise dealerships’ online presence neglects to even promote service pricing, the consumer’s mind is thinking that very thought — $5 off what? There is no pricing, which leads to the consumer making an assumption of what the pricing could be. There is no value built into the “why” to opt for service at your multi-million-dollar facility. 

Simply put, there is little if no effort at all produced from fixed ops within websites today. So what if the messaging was changed and with it the consumer’s perception?

• Full Synthetic Oil Change – Starting at $44.95
• We Only Use Manufacturer-Certified Fluids and Parts
• Our Factory-Trained Service Technicians Are Skilled on Working in Every Toyota Vehicle
• For Our Clients’ Comfort – We offer a state-of-the-art facility and customer lounge featuring free Wi-Fi, full-service bistro, shuttle van or loaner vehicle provided and a Starbucks barista

How about that for a value proposition!

So, how can a dealership today reverse the current stigma? Here’s a hint, it’s not that difficult. The $19.95 Jiffy Lube Oil Change is never priced that way when the consumer walks out the door.   

Clear and Transparent Pricing

Most OEMs have been pushing dealers to create a more inviting customer waiting area as well as digital signage that gives consumers a compelling reason to continue servicing their vehicles with the dealership. Some companies do an amazing job creating visuals within the service drive and customer lounge. With transparent pricing on services from AWD alignments to brake pad replacement, it starts to reverse the narrative that a franchise dealership is uncompetitive as it relates to those services.   

How can a dealership start the process of winning back their service customers? By displaying pricing on both a service menu page and service detail pages within their website. 

Considering consumers search online and price shop everything today, creating a service menu page that lists 12-15 of your dealership’s most commonly performed services, clearly laying out pricing and a brief overview of those services, then offering links to pages that explain each service more in-depth is a great strategy to educate the customer and give them the information they are looking for. This is also a great way to reinforce the franchise dealership’s narrative. We provide the most value to a consumer — with competitive pricing, state-of-the-art facilities and customer perks that include Wi-Fi, comfortable lounges with premium amenities — the storyline begins to shift.   

Educate the Customer…Then Own the Search

Most dealerships have 20 pages or less of fixed operations-related content with their website. That is being generous and most certainly I have seen very few pages that educate the consumer on services needed, but a web page like Figure 2 educates the consumer and displays upfront pricing. What is the biggest driver of customer pay ROs today? Consumers are opting to own their vehicle longer.

Services such as alignment, brake pad replacement, set of four tires replacement and fluid flushes are commonly performed on vehicles with more than 50,000 miles, if not sooner. However, I can say without any hesitation that alignment service pages are few and far between. There’s no information about why that service is needed, around what mileage you want to think about having that service performed and what the general starting at cost would be.  

What better prize than the No. 1 rank on Google? See Figure 3. Your website now informs your customers about the pros and cons of getting an alignment service while giving them the information they desire to make an informed decision. Then, your website and dealership are rewarded with position No. 1 inside Google search rankings. Talk about a win/win for the dealership.  

As I often tell our clients, the narrative exists because dealers have allowed it to exist. By taking a few simple steps, consumer perception can change and change quite rapidly. If you have ever sat inside a Pep Boys or Jiffy Lube, you realize immediately that you get what you pay for. Then couple that with the fact that the spend is almost identical on each service at the local franchise dealership. The mindset is forever altered.   

When looking at the aftermarket industry as a whole, the opportunity to get a fraction of that can improve profitability for a franchise dealership, allowing that dealer to mitigate the potential decline in vehicle sales, while also instilling repeat business in both service and sales when the customer decides to purchase their next vehicle.
Owen Moon

You May Also Like

Autel, MOTOR Partner to Bring OEM Data to Ultra Series Tablets

Autel Ultra series tablet users can access automotive service and repair content within days of it being published by the OEM.

Autel scan tools, diagnostic tools

Autel has announced that they have partnered with MOTOR Information Systems to provide an improved experience for users and more streamlined access to OEM repair information using MOTOR’s TruSpeed Repair. MOTOR TruSpeed Repair will be available for integration into Autel’s diagnostics software on all North American Ultra series tablets including ADAS-capable tools.

Top 3 Ways to Avoid Warranty Audit Headaches in 2024

Avoiding warranty claim debits can be a daunting task, fraught with complicated processes and procedures.

warranty audit headaches
ASE Workshops at NADA to Focus on EV Safety, Technician Recruitment and Retention

Learn strategies to better attract and retain entry-level technicians as well as how to develop and maintain a safe work environment and skill set for your extended EV team members.

Automotive Service Excellence logo - ASE logo
Hunter’s Ultimate ADAS Gains Approval from Nissan, Infiniti

Ultimate ADAS will be on display with frequent demos in booth 3721W at NADA in Las Vegas, Feb. 1-4.

Invisible Protection: The Importance of Paint Protection Film for Autos

Designed to act as an invisible barrier against road debris, stone chips, bug splatter, bird droppings and harsh weather conditions, PPF plays a crucial role in safeguarding a vehicle’s paint finish.

Invisible Protection: The Importance of Paint Protection Film for Autos

Other Posts

BendPak to Debut Eight-Armed Car Lift Concept at NADA 2024

The Octa-Flex is a radical new two-post lift design that features two sets of arms: triple-telescoping swing arms plus all-new integrated lift-assist arms.

BendPak to Debut Eight-Armed Car Lift Concept at NADA Expo
The Don’ts and Dos of Outsourcing OEM Warranty Administration

A good service will provide onsite training, helping the advisors and techs write better ROs while freeing up management.

The Don’ts and Dos of Outsourcing OEM Warranty Administration
The Coats Company Joins with Victor Capital Partners

Coats will continue to be led locally by its existing executive team.

The Coats Company logo
Impel Expands into Aftermarket to Meet Demand for AI-Powered Customer Lifecycle Management

This move aims to address the increasing demand for AI solutions in the $535 billion independent service industry.