Why Digital Retailing Is Increasing Fraud, and What To Do About It

Why Digital Retailing Is Increasing Fraud, and What You Can Do About It

By introducing readily available technologies into the online and in-store workflows, dealers can save themselves a lot of headaches.

No doubt, digital retailing is here to stay in automotive, and it is growing like wildfire. However, while most of the world thinks the auto industry is worried most about getting inventory levels back to normal, what they’re actually worried about is fraud — and the increase in digital retailing is the primary culprit with profit erosion as a significant threat.

According to mid-year industry estimates, approximately one out of every five car buyers were considered primarily digital, meaning they’ve done more than 50% of the work to buy a vehicle online1. Separately, according to the 2021 Cox Automotive Car Buyer Financing Journey Study, 96% of consumers said they are willing to apply for their financing online. These consumers revealed that online or digital platforms save time, and they tend to be more satisfied with their dealership experience than those consumers who take the same steps in person2.

Simply put, car buyers not only want to do their transactions online, they are increasingly doing just that.

New Opportunities Bring New Challenges

But therein lies the new challenge for dealers and lender partners. While they’ve seemingly solved one problem of how to give car buyers what they want — online purchase options — they’ve opened up Pandora’s box for more fraudulent threats.

This can’t come as a big surprise, especially since the broader retail industry has also been dealing with similar scenarios in e-commerce. Afterall, e-commerce is fast-paced, competitive and ever-changing. Digital purchase and finance resources such as mobile apps and wallets, cryptocurrency and financial technology are all now contributing to the next fraud opportunity.

During the pandemic, e-commerce fraud increased significantly worldwide. Mid-to-large general merchandise retailers faced 70% more fraud attempts per month during the 2020 lockdown than prior to that3.

More Fraud, But Dealers Don’t Know What to Do

Auto dealers and lenders now find themselves facing similarities. According to a recent study, 84% of dealerships have directly experienced identity fraud at their dealership since the pandemic, with a third seeing an over 20% increase in identity fraud-related activities since the pandemic started. And, in just the past year, 79% directly experienced an identity fraud-related vehicle loss at their dealership4.

The report, based on a survey of over 700 auto dealerships across the U.S., reveals that while dealerships cite identity fraud as their top fraud challenge/concern, and almost unanimously agree that its increase is because of the increased digitization of the deal, 67% lack adequate identity fraud protections.

When asked to explain the increase in identity fraud, 95% relate it directly to the increase in the digitization of the deal and remote buying experiences, with 86% predicting that as more of the transaction moves online, identity fraud will increase and become harder to prevent. The report also reveals that losses are not limited to identity fraud, with the vast majority of dealerships reporting an increase in loan application fraud in the past year. Seventy-seven percent saw a 10-20% increase or more, with over one-third reporting that one in every 100 applications at their dealership was fraudulent.

The report also investigates what dealerships have been doing to prevent fraud: “photocopying the driver’s license / ID” (64%) is number one, with the “Red Flags Rule” (56%) at number two. Only 33% reported using critical document authentication as part of their process, a significant disconnect.

Using Everyday Technology to Prevent New Fraud

Currently, most dealers utilize scanning technology to scan a person’s driver’s license to satisfy compliance, procedural checklists and to OCR the data to populate the CRM at the time of loan application or even during a test drive. While this process is important, it lacks a significantly critical element that can potentially prevent or even thwart the vast amount of synthetic fraud attempts.

Scanning of the driver’s license is important, but dealers must also utilize verification technology to validate the driver’s license and the person’s true identity. This additional step helps to validate and verify the individual via address verification, red flag, OFAC and synthetic fraud checks. It is estimated that a vast majority of dealers today still don’t include this verification step in their process, which is why photocopying is muscle memory for dealers, and a false sense of security.

Furthermore, sales personnel are repeatedly having over-the-phone customer inquiries send them a “text” of their driver’s license. These images (NPI /PII) can remain on the salesperson’s phone indefinitely, which is a direct violation of one of the new 2022 Safeguards Rules. Dealers and their partners can leverage new technologies today that combines prescreen, prequalification and ID verification tools to prevent fraudulent activity from happening.

With the proliferation of today’s digital and online shopping, the verification and validation of one’s identity is even more critical when a potential fraudster is sitting in the privacy of their own home filling out a loan application. Mobile and ID scan technologies are now widely used in online banking applications, and these could significantly help dealers during an online transaction.

By introducing these readily available technologies into the online and in-store workflows, dealers and their lender partners can save themselves a lot of headaches — and even more toward the bottom line.


1: https://www.wardsauto.com/dealers/auto-industry-transforms-signing-dotted-line
2: https://www.coxautoinc.com/news/2021-car-buyer-financing-journey-study/
3: https://internetretailing.net/growth-2000/ecommerce-fraud-trends-to-look-out-for-in-2022/
4: https://www.prweb.com/releases/2022/10/prweb18975650.htm

You May Also Like

The Dealership Flywheel: A Perspective from X-Amazonian

Customer obsession is key. Every dealership must have processes in place to never fail a customer.

service customer and mechanic

As your dealership heads into 2024, it’s common to reflect back on the previous year and identify possible areas of improvement. As you reflect, consider things like whether or not you’ve had about the same number of people coming into your service department each day of the week or month of the year. As you reflect back on this past year’s sales and inventory hurdles, you undoubtedly know which months your store sold the most used or new cars.

New Research Reveals Age and Gender Differences in Vehicle Add-On Purchases

Are there certain age/gender demographics with a higher propensity of purchasing any specific set of VPPs? This study sheds light on consumer preferences and priorities when it comes to safeguarding and maintaining vehicles.

study about age and gender differences - man and woman
How Generative AI Is Impacting Auto Lending Compliance

What is often left out of recent headlines, is the extraordinary power of AI to reduce harm, including fair lending and discrimination risks.

5 Predictions for Front-Line Chat Solutions

In the next few years, prepare for a chat solution that must act like a personal greeter to every customer who visits your digital showroom.

Maximizing Fleet Uptime: A Dealer’s Guide

This guide provides actionable insights for dealers to ensure their fleets are always on the move.

Other Posts

Cox’s Dealertrack Adds Synthetic ID Fraud Alert

With the new offering, dealers receive an alert when a customer may be using synthetic ID and get a risk level assessment score when pulling credit.

Experian Unveils Tool to Help Dealers Mitigate Fraud Losses

Fraud Protect is a web-based application that helps automotive dealers detect and prevent fraud while maintaining a positive shopping experience for the consumer.

Cox Dealertrack Adds Synthetic ID Fraud Alert as Part of Compliance Solution

With the new offering dealers receive an alert when a customer may be using synthetic ID and get a risk level assessment score when pulling credit.

Protect Your Dealership

Thirty-four percent of dealers are still lost concerning certain key components of Safeguards law compliance.