Questionable F&I Practices Aren’t Worth the Risk

Questionable F&I Practices Aren’t Worth the Risk to Your Business

Regulators are taking a hawk-eyed view of the market right now. Now is not the time to get fast and loose with your deal jackets.

Regulators Are Watching

The automotive market is hot right now and the scramble to come out ahead is on for your dealership. But beware because, on the flipside, regulators are signaling that they’re taking a hawk-eyed view of the market right now and have made it clear they’re watching. Now is not the time to get fast and loose with your deal jackets.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) released a statement at the end of February saying that it’s got its eyes on car loans, specifically auto lending competition and loan-to-value ratios. It made clear that it will be working with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Federal Reserve Bank Board of Governors to address market issues. 

You’re in the business of making money, but you’re also responsible for staying out of the crosshairs of those groups I name-dropped above. A fine from one of them will wipe out any effort or money you might have earned on a murky deal and put you in the red. It also damages your reputation for customer service and as a good business in the community.

Here are a few things you need to remember with your deal jackets. 

Credit Applications

I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve seen a dealer changing customer credit applications fraudulently, violating several regulations and requirements. Changing credit applications or not adhering to the Fair Lending Act isn’t an acceptable business practice and certainly doesn’t help your customer. Your information must be accurate. You would not believe how many dealers mark the rate up, particularly with customers whose primary language isn’t English.

Payment Packing

The FTC has transparent and stringent guidelines for payment packing to ensure those customer payments aren’t inflated with fraudulent figures. Some dealers will intentionally give inaccurate information to a customer to manipulate the price, sell the product and make more money. The rules clearly state you can’t do this. 

Any dealership that extends credit must follow Regulation Z, the Truth in Lending Act (TILA). TILA protects customers’ interactions with all lenders, including car dealers, by requiring the complete disclosure of the following:
• Cost of credit 
• Term of the loan 
• The total amount of the loan 
• Interest rate, etc. 

The penalties for not complying with these requirements can range from a couple thousand to millions of dollars. And again, it puts your business reputation in jeopardy. I once uncovered a significant amount of payment-packing within a dealership group. Once the issue came to light, the general sales manager and finance director implicated in the case were fired. The turnover lead to a decrease in sales and a hit to their reputation in the community.

Red Flag Rules

It’s easy to ignore red flags and Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) rules. You need to run your customers by OFAC’s list of Specially Designated Nationals to ensure they’re not listed as a terrorist or money launderers. Disregarding this search can cost you into the millions. It’s also just as critical to your business’s credibility that you’re keeping an eye out for any potential identity theft red flags. I’ve seen dealers bypass this rule to sell a vehicle. 

We’re all trying to make the best of the current economy and turbulence in the automotive industry. Just knowing that regulatory agencies are on the alert can be more than half the battle to protecting your business, reputation and your employees. Noncompliance and its associated costs are never worth the sale.

You May Also Like

Elevating the FTC Safeguards: Embracing a Defense in Depth Approach

In a serious cyberattack, a single security control may not be able to mitigate all the damage, but multiple controls working in unison can.

Elevating the FTC Safeguards: Embracing a Defense in Depth Approach

In the ever-evolving landscape of cybersecurity, one fundamental principle remains clear: compliance does not always equal security. Auto dealers must be proactive in protecting their customers’ data and in maintaining their brand’s integrity. Applying the security concept of defense in depth is essential to fortify FTC Safeguards compliance and ensure robust security.

Why Dealers Should Care About the Coming Auto Insurance Recovery

The anticipated upswing of the auto insurance market in 2024 — and lower insurance rates that come along with it — should have dealers celebrating.

Why Dealers Should Care About the Coming Auto Insurance Recovery - Polly
F&I 2024 Dealer Outlook: How Online Options Will Help Dealers Better Serve Customers

Dealers must find ways to maximize F&I sales opportunities, because in this highly competitive landscape, dealerships rely on the sale of these products to enhance their bottom line and remain competitive.

F&I Outlook from Protective Asset Protection
Is a Vehicle Test Drive Still Relevant Today?

An important part of the process, the test drive is the strongest opportunity to build the customer’s positive emotions around the vehicle.

Is a Vehicle Test Drive Still Relevant Today?
Protect Your Dealership

Thirty-four percent of dealers are still lost concerning certain key components of Safeguards law compliance.

Other Posts

How Dealership Texting Software is Changing the Game

Dealership texting software is setting new standards in customer service and sales efficiency, proving to be an indispensable asset in the modern dealership toolkit.

How Dealership Texting Software is Changing the Game - Tecobi
How Women In Automotive Benefits the Auto Industry

WIA seeks to break down old stereotypes in a way that truly creates channels of opportunity where both women and men can participate.

Women In Automotive
Are You The Captain Now?…or Is Bad Marketing Steering Your Ship?

It’s time to get out of the mindset of cut, cut, cut, and into the mindset of spending wisely for your long-term success.

Is Bad Marketing Steering Your Ship?
She’s Not Just the Dealer’s Daughter or Wife!

In this interview, Rita Case shares her journey from pioneering automotive franchises to overcoming industry challenges.

Rita Case interview with Susan Givens for AutoSuccess