Cox Automotive Study: Shortages Hold Back Service Departments

Cox Automotive Study: Shortages Hold Back Service Departments

The study reveals dealership market is share up to 34% with another 66% of the service department market still up for grabs.

Despite current headwinds and market conditions, dealership service centers remain resilient and continue to be among the most preferred service providers. According to the 2021 Cox Automotive Service Industry Study, 34% of consumers prefer dealership service centers, a 1% increase from 2018, and ahead of general repair shops. While this is great news for franchise dealers, there is still a majority of the market dealerships aren’t capturing – translating to $214 billion in potential revenue.

Dealership service centers are the most preferred because of their existing relationships. In fact, 55% of consumers say it is because the dealership knows their vehicle. On the other hand, dealerships continue to combat the perception they are overpriced and expensive. The top barriers to returning to the dealership are not only cost, but also location according to consumer rankings, all of which makes way for what owners consider easier and more convenient options, like general repair shops. On top of that, nearly 1-in-4 consumers also say their dealership service visits take longer than expected, adding to their frustration.

Dealerships Working Against Operational Challenges

Exacerbated by the pandemic, service departments cite part delays from manufacturers (58%) and finding or hiring the right technicians (45%) as their top operational challenges, and both can directly impact the consumer experience, including the notion that service departments take longer than expected. On average, dealerships cite a decline in the consumer satisfaction they deliver, with only 55% of dealers believing satisfaction has improved in the past 12 months (down from 71% when surveyed in 2018). Specific to staffing, 57% of dealership respondents say their service department is not fully staffed, and 80% expect these labor shortages to continue or worsen in the future. The majority (60%) also say the service technician is the top role they plan to grow this year, so there is a focus on investing in this area of the business.

“The industry is ripe for transforming the consumer experience,” said Tracy Fred, vice president of operations for Xtime. “Despite a challenging marketplace, opportunities exist to better leverage digital tools to deliver on and even exceed consumer expectations, while also offsetting some operational challenges. Elevating the entire service experience with a consumer-first mindset and the use of technology can help raise overall profits, capture additional market share and help mitigate the frustrations service departments are currently facing.”  

Opportunity Exists to Better Leverage Digital Solutions to Improve the Service Experience

Dealership service centers offering digital features have a more positive outlook. Of the dealers saying the experience has improved in the past year, they more often offer services like service pick-up and delivery, ridesharing, progress tracking, online cost estimates, mobile check-in and other digital services. Not only are they offering these conveniences, but they have the added benefit of meeting consumer demand for a more digital service experience. 

Car owners particularly want the ability to schedule their appointment online, and it seems the dealer is striving to meet consumer needs there with 74% of dealers offering this option today. Of those owners scheduling online, 91% are highly satisfied with the experience; however, a third of consumers are unsure if their service provider offers this feature, which is consistent with the 2018 Cox Automotive Service Industry Study. 

Consumers also want to review and approve repair estimates online (67%) and access their vehicle service history (66%), which according to those surveyed are among the most critical digital features a service center should offer and provide an added level of transparency and convenience to the service experience.

Top Performers Excel Across Efficiency and Consumer Experience, Helping Boost Profits

Top performing service departments have a consumer-first mindset and use technology to enhance the experience by offering digital tools and convenience-focused services, like rideshare and reviewing and approving repair orders online. Nearly all top-performing dealers surveyed (99%) agree that improving consumer experience is an important focus moving forward. 

“Consumers continue to stress the importance of a digital experience, and dealerships must evolve and offer flexibility by enhancing online capabilities,” said Fred. “Meeting consumer demand for convenience by considering new service lines like ridesharing also can help combat location as a barrier. These same services can also be leveraged as new staffing strategies, like enabling Lyft for service pick-up and delivery to allow your existing staff to focus elsewhere.”

You May Also Like

Used Car Sourcing and Predictable Appraisal Accuracy

Trade-ins remain essential, so when their owners walk through the door, give them the fairest offer you can — and be sure the spread you need isn’t diluted by appraisal oversights.

Used Car Sourcing and Predictable Appraisal Accuracy

Dealerships in 2024 will continue to face used car sourcing challenges. I recently read an article that netted the issue: "Dealers navigating a used-vehicle market that already allows little room for error are eyeing another obstacle: worsening used-car availability."

According to BlackBook data:

Seven to 10 million fewer new vehicles were sold during 2020-2022 compared to 2016-2019.

Unlocking Your Dealership’s Hidden Revenue: The Power of Warranty Reimbursements

Partnering with a qualified vendor to ensure you receive what you’re legally owed is more than just advantageous — it’s a necessity.

Unlocking Your Dealership's Hidden Revenue: The Power of Warranty Reimbursements
PRT Launches 22 Complete Strut Assemblies

The release represents more than 12 million vehicles in new coverage.

PRT Launches 22 Complete Strut Assembly New Products
Autel, MOTOR Partner to Bring OEM Data to Ultra Series Tablets

Autel Ultra series tablet users can access automotive service and repair content within days of it being published by the OEM.

Autel scan tools, diagnostic tools
Top 3 Ways to Avoid Warranty Audit Headaches in 2024

Avoiding warranty claim debits can be a daunting task, fraught with complicated processes and procedures.

warranty audit headaches

Other Posts

Cox’s Dealertrack Adds Synthetic ID Fraud Alert

With the new offering, dealers receive an alert when a customer may be using synthetic ID and get a risk level assessment score when pulling credit.

Cox Presents 2024 Leader in Sustainability Award

The Cox Automotive Leader in Sustainability Award recognizes a dealership for outstanding in-dealership sustainability programs related to waste reduction, energy or water conservation and focused on innovation, creativity, and engagement with its employees and the community.

Cox Automotive Charges Forward with New EV Battery Solutions Facility in Georgia

Cox Automotive supports practices that enable the extension of EV battery first lives and end-of-life reuse and recovery treatments.

Cox Automotive charges forward with new EV Battery Solutions facility in Georgia.
Cox Dealertrack Adds Synthetic ID Fraud Alert as Part of Compliance Solution

With the new offering dealers receive an alert when a customer may be using synthetic ID and get a risk level assessment score when pulling credit.