What's The ROI on my Digital Advertising?

What’s The ROI on my Digital Advertising?

We have different piggy banks in the automotive industry. Dealers need to deposit local, profitable sales and service transactions into their piggy banks to measure growth and success. I wrote this article in hopes of gaining feedback and insight on a subject where I believe our industry could improve.

We have different piggy banks in the automotive industry. Dealers need to deposit local, profitable sales and service transactions into their piggy banks to measure growth and success. I wrote this article in hopes of gaining feedback and insight on a subject where I believe our industry could improve.

A new, smart client of ours asked me a basic question that served as the catalyst for this article. Before I could answer, he said, “You are not allowed to use any of these tech words: Conversion, Impression Share, Clicks, Cost Per Click, Cost Per Lead, Time On Site, Bounce Rate, Engagement, VDP or anything similar. You can use words like Transactions, Sales, Repair Orders, Gross Profit and any other industry term you like as long as it involves us making money.” Seemed like a reasonable request and right down my alley.

His question: “What’s the return on my digital advertising investment? I know how much money I spend with Google, Bing and Facebook. Prove to me the transactions and money we deposit in return for our investment.”

In their new digital playbook for dealers, Google classifies the ability to answer this question in the “advanced attribution” category, which is basically their futuristic bucket because of how rare it is for a digital vendor in the automotive industry to prove attribution. Many dealers I know would respond with, “Are you kidding me? If you can’t answer this basic question….” This is where the disconnect has happened in the industry. The media that capture the most consumer data should be the easiest and most logical to determine an ROI based on a dealership’s actual sales and service transactions. Dealerships today are putting more of their ad budget into digital media. Naturally, they want to fish where the fish are — but very few digital agencies can identify how many fish are actually caught and how much they weigh.

After all, we have the data, right? In order to determine an ROI, all you need is two readily available pieces of data. First, you need at least one unique data point for a consumer who identified themselves while engaged in shopping online, like their name, address, email or their mobile phone number they may have used to call, text or chat. The second is a list of all the sales and service transactions and the gross profits associated with each of those transactions. Just cross reference the people who engaged with your advertising against your transactions. Pretty basic, but why do hardly any digital agencies do this? A dealership could get that information from TrueCar in less than a minute, but not from their digital agency? Is that logical?

This new client asked me for something so simple and he claimed he just can’t get this basic transactional ROI data anywhere else. All he wanted was a list of everybody who used Google, Bing or Facebook, who clearly identified themselves by calling, filling out a form, claiming an offer, chatting, or some other way who also completed a transaction at his dealership. He then asked us to divide the matched list into folks who had already done business with the dealership before and those who had not. For a dealer, that makes perfect sense and connects all the logical dots from his investment in Google, Bing and Facebook right into their piggy bank.

You simply add up all the money the dealership actually made on real transactions where customers were influenced enough to identify themselves and subtract the digital spend to acquire those customers. So, let’s say Susan Jones, who never purchased a car from this dealership, saw a Google ad on a pre-owned vehicle, clicked the ad to call the dealership from her cell phone and spoke for four minutes and 18 second. She then provided the dealership with the exact same mobile number she originally called from (two basic data points) when she took delivery the next day. The dealership made $4,000. Let’s also say this happened 10 times in a month. You get the math.

In a previous article, I provided a step-by-step process on how to do this. It’s not rocket science, which is why so many other types of marketing vendors do this routinely. Very few digital agencies, however, consider a sales or service transaction as the ultimate conversion. Let that sink in. Rather, they use technical jargon which collectively sounds impressive, but doesn’t necessarily ring the cash register. After all, the only reason a dealer advertises anywhere is to “ring the register.” Why is this considered advanced or aspirational? A transaction is the only way dealers make money, and the only way they can properly attribute their advertising to a real ROI. They certainly can’t deposit “clicks and views” into their bank accounts.

Some of you out there will read this and claim this is trying to give 100 percent attribution to a particular search or click. That isn’t the case at all. This purely provides a starting point that shows the influence each medium has in the actual buying process. We can get into complex attribution models in another article — but not until we answer these simple questions dealers are asking first.

My hope is the best digital agencies in the industry will improve the methods we all use to deliver an ROI and a better level of standardization develops. I see dealerships changing digital vendors with totally unrealistic expectations based on promises that sound incredible, but often fail to deliver a return on their investment. In the meantime, we are going to keep working closely with companies like Google, Bing and Facebook to include simpler, easier to understand transaction-based reporting.


You May Also Like

Why Data Security Must Be a Priority in Today’s Automotive Retail Market

Dealers who gain a better understanding of data security and how data relates to industry trends will ultimately find themselves in a better position to achieve long-term goals.

By Aaron Baldwin, chief product officer at automotiveMastermind

In today's ever-evolving automotive retail environment, data security must be a top priority rather than an afterthought. This matter only grows in importance as dealers collect and store a growing amount of sensitive personal information for thousands of customers through their sales and marketing efforts.

The Digital Dilemma: How to Rethink Sales and Delivery to Drive a Successful Car Buying Future

By taking the right steps, traditional car dealers can still compete, win and flourish, even as digital sales become more prolific.

Revolutionizing Auto Service: How Digital Tools Are Transforming the Auto Dealership Landscape

Remote diagnostics, over-the-air updates, faster service appointments and less vehicle downtime all represent the emerging reality of remote automotive services.

147,348 Reasons Why Customer Experience & Dealership Loyalty Matter – The Power of a Point

That’s the annual average revenue increase a dealership can expect to realize by raising its customer satisfaction score by a single point.

In a Fickle Market, How Do We Continue Winning Customers for Life?

It is imperative to ask the right questions to find out what motivates your customers. Getting to know the customer means getting to know their needs and that benefits everyone. 

Other Posts

Where Did My Google Traffic Go?

If your Google search traffic has been declining, check your keywords and your rank report to get your full SEO picture.

If your Google search traffic has been declining, check your keywords and your rank report to get your full SEO picture.
Google Merges 2 Ad Formats Used Most by Dealers

The new ad format, launching this summer, will bring new features that car dealerships can tap into to make their advertising dollars go further.

Alarming Number of Dealers Are Still Not Ready for This Year’s Safeguards Rule — Here’s What to Know

The ruling oversees how financial institutions protect consumer data, and dealerships must implement changes to protect their consumer data.

Before You Make a Video…

Here are a few tips for creating value proposition, service special or test-drive videos. With a little planning you can quickly produce high-quality videos for your dealership.

taking video of car with phone