Traditional Versus Digital: The Debate Stops Here - AutoSuccessOnline

Traditional Versus Digital: The Debate Stops Here

“But we now live in a world where a majority of consumers spend a majority of their time online and that’s where smart marketers, and their budgets, should be as well.”

During my career, I’ve represented well-known brands at ad agencies and media organizations, and I never fully understood why companies continue to sink significant budget into traditional marketing. At its core, traditional media is way too expensive and extremely difficult to track — not to mention growing out of favor with consumers.

For example, total weekday circulations for newspapers fell 8 percent last year for both print and digital, and last year’s newspaper revenue was a third of what it was just 10 years ago — 2016 marked the 28th consecutive year of declines. Traditional TV viewing has declined over the past five years by an average of nearly 21 percent across all age groups, excluding adults aged 65 and older. Radio is about the only medium that hasn’t suffered heavy losses, although Millennials prefer streaming radio over traditional radio.

I’m not a person who strictly believes that if it isn’t digital, it won’t work — there are exceptions to every rule. But we now live in a world where a majority of consumers spend a majority of their time online and that’s where smart marketers, and their budgets, should be as well. This is especially true given the fact studies show it costs approximately $150 of digital marketing to sell one car compared to $1,581 — more than 10 times — in traditional media spending.

Following are tips for dealers and for the agencies that represent facets of their business. I call it the “80/Supplemental-20 Rule” and here are some fundamentals.

Let Your Brand Do the Heavy Lifting

OEMs spend a ton of money (just look at the Super Bowl) to build your brand in the traditional sense. They are well equipped to run national TV spots, take on full-page, four-color ads in major media outlets or national radio campaigns promoting sweet sales events. They have tools and teams of people at their access to help strategize, create, plan, implement and track brand campaigns on a national scope, bolstering your efforts on a local level. So, let your brand do the heavy lifting.

Commit 80 Percent to Digital, 20 Percent to Targeted Traditional Campaigns

Commit the bulk of your annual marketing budget, about 80 percent, to digital and third-party leads. When done right, it’s affordable, effective, easy to measure and helps you reach local customers beyond your efforts right where, and when, you want them — online, while they’re researching their next vehicle purchase. Dedicate roughly 20 percent of your annual marketing budget to strategic traditional campaigns, such as sports broadcasts (where local viewers tune in live at the same time) or ever-popular live and local news broadcasts. Lulls in regional dealer association advertising campaigns are opportune times.

Remember that Digital Companies Invest Heavily in Driving Consumers to You

It’s really that simple. An effective digital lead-generation company, for example, will spend virtually no money building its brand, and instead will devote a significant budget in expert SEM to reach and convert millions of monthly car shoppers into dealer Website traffic and leads so you don’t have to. This is particularly critical in sales declines when conquesting products help you reach and engage competitive consumers to drive them to your Website. After this much wider net is cast on your behalf, be sure to invest in digital tools that convert Website visitors into showroom visitors. Products like virtual showrooms, text lead management systems, shop-by-payment calculators and instant retargeting technology have proven to be very useful tools in Website optimization and conversions.

Let’s stop the debate and be honest with ourselves. A majority of today’s car buyers are online and you should be there too — the right way, and for a lot less money.

Beth Bartlett

You May Also Like

Google Analytics for Dummies

GA4 can help you understand which marketing sources drove traffic to your website, allowing you to compare one to another.

Google Analytics for Dummies A Simple GA4 Guide for Non-Analytics People

A Simple GA4 Guide for Non-Analytics People

G4? GA4? Google Analytics? Are they all the same, and how do they relate to the metrics my website vendor sends me? 

First off, I don't sell any products related to analytics or analytics consulting. Our company does help our dealer partners with this area, but this article is purely intended to inform, and I don't have a dog in this fight. My product is in the digital marketing realm, so we interface a ton with analytics. Moreover, I get dozens of analytics questions every day, and there’s understandably a lot of confusion about this topic.

Unlocking the Value of Your Data. Don’t Let it Go to Waste.

Explore expert Bobby Gaudreau’s insights on overcoming data challenges in auto dealerships, focusing on CRM and DMS optimization for marketing success.

Unlocking the Value of Your Data. Don't Let it Go to Waste.
You Want Me to Pay for WHAT?!

Arming yourself with this firsthand knowledge will let you make informed decisions and allocate your budget toward increased profitability in ways you simply cannot hope to when you’re playing telephone with your manager charged with executing on marketing.

Wikimotive, trade shows, marketing,
Crafting a Cohesive Brand Identity

Upholding a cohesive brand image is vital. Learn how photography plays a pivotal role in reinforcing a dealership’s professionalism.

Crafting a Cohesive Brand Identity The Impact of Professional Photos in Maintaining Consistency Across Marketing Materials
Is Marketing Both the Problem and Solution for the EV Market?

Marketing can answer consumers’ questions and demystify the EV buying journey.

Is Marketing Both the Problem and Solution for the EV Market? myAutoIQ article

Other Posts

Riding the Wave of Innovation: How Advanced Data Tools Are Transforming Automotive Appraisals

The ability to customize appraisal tools according to specific dealership needs and market dynamics ensures that appraisals are closely aligned with strategic goals, giving dealerships a competitive edge.

Riding the Wave of Innovation: How Advanced Data Tools Are Transforming Automotive Appraisals
Selecting the Ideal Car Lift for EV Servicing

When choosing the right car lift for servicing electric vehicles there are several key factors to consider.

Key Factors in Selecting the Ideal Car Lift for Electric Vehicle Servicing- Coats
Exploring Educational Opportunities with NADA and ATD

The comprehensive NADA and ATD programs, complemented by an extensive array of resources, foster excellence and innovation within the automotive retail landscape.

Exploring Educational Opportunities with NADA and ATD
F&I 2024 Dealer Outlook: How Online Options Will Help Dealers Better Serve Customers

Dealers must find ways to maximize F&I sales opportunities, because in this highly competitive landscape, dealerships rely on the sale of these products to enhance their bottom line and remain competitive.

F&I Outlook from Protective Asset Protection