What Is a Service Advisor Really Worth? - AutoSuccessOnline

What Is a Service Advisor Really Worth?

As a dealer or general manager you should visit with your advisors daily, let them know you care, acknowledge a good job, correct substandard performance immediately and edify these advisors to their customers, their managers and their fellow employees.

We’ve talked about what it takes to attain 100-percent service absorption in your dealership by implementing your “front end” (sales) processes in the “back end” (fixed ops — the back bone) of your dealership. To reach that goal, you must first realize and appreciate what a service advisor is really worth. — Don Reed, CEO, DealerPRO Training

What Makes a Good Service Advisor?
To begin with, let’s determine what a good service advisor’s profile should be and then we will determine what he or she is actually worth. First of all, an advisor must have good communication skills and should enjoy dealing with the public.

Generally, usually, most of the time a good technician does not make a good advisor because they think and talk in technical terms that your customers do not understand, which of course is not conducive to high CSI scores or owner retention.

Service advisors should dress like professional salespeople, similar to your sales staff in the showroom, and they must be compensated based upon their individual sales performance in areas such as total parts and labor sales and customer satisfaction.

They need to be given daily, weekly and monthly sales goals and receive written daily performance evaluations, which means they must be held accountable for their performance, just like a salesperson in your sales department. Last of all, service advisors must be trained in the “road to a sale.”

Great Expectations
Now that you have recruited people with good communication skills, compensated them based on their individual performance, dressed them like professional salespeople and trained them how to become a professional salesperson, let’s look at the results that you can expect to achieve:

  • Increase in sales per customer pay RO
  • Increase in repair order count
  • Increase in CSI
  • Increase in owner retention
  • Customer pay labor gross profit at 70 percent of sales
  • Customer pay parts gross profit at 45 percent of sales
  • One item repair orders at 10 percent or less
  • Increase in “fixed right first visit”
  • Increase in technicians’ productivity
  • Service absorption at 100 percent

If all of the above sounds like a good thing to you, then let’s determine what this service advisor is worth. Please review the following outline where I am comparing the “worth” of a service advisor to the “worth” of a vehicle salesperson.

What Does Your Average Service Advisor Produce?
(Based on industry averages and guidelines)

Total ROs per day 15
Average HPRO 1.5
Total labor hours sold per day (A X B) 22.5
Effective labor rate $90
Total labor sales per day (C X D) $2,028
Labor gross profit percent of sales 75 percent
Total labor gross profit (E X F)    $1,519
Parts to labor ratio 80 percent
Total parts sales per day (E X H) $1,620
Parts Gross Profit % of Sales 40 percent
Total parts gross profit (I X J)    $648


A well-trained service advisor can generate more than twice the gross profit as a new vehicle salesperson. Here’s proof:

Gross Profit Comparison                                          Monthly         Annually
Average # of units sold per salesperson                                 11                        132
Salesperson gross profit @ $2,000 PRU                         $22,000             $264,000
Service advisor gross profit @ 1.5 HPRO                        $45,507               $546,084
(21 days)

An advisor is often compensated at about 10 percent of gross profit while an automobile salesperson is compensated at about 20 percent but produces half of what an advisor does.

Compensation Comparison
Salesperson compensation @ 20 percent of gross profit            $52,800
Service advisor compensation @ 10 percent of gross profit       $54,608

Who gives you the bigger bang for the buck?

Answer: Service advisors give you twice the bang for your buck!

An outstanding salesperson must sell about one vehicle per day (23 per month) to match the profit generated by an average service advisor.

Training can produce an increase of .5 HPRO. This increased HPRO activity annualizes to about $300,000 per year on 500 ROs. On 750 ROs it jumps to $450,000 and at 1,000 ROs per month it soars to $600,000 for the year.

Let’s convert this gross profit into front-end language for comparison purposes. Using our example of $2,000 gross profit PRU, let’s divide that number into our potential for gross profit improvement as outlined above:

  • .5 HPRO improvement on 500 ROs = $300,000 = 150 New Units
  • .5 HPRO improvement on 750 ROs = $450,000 = 225 New Units
  • .5 HPRO improvement on 1,000 ROs = $600,000 = 300 New Units

Your service advisors can be a source of constant and consistent profit improvement, not subject to the type of price comparisons or negotiating common to the retail sales environment.

Profit Development: Salesperson vs. Service Advisor

Who gets the most sales training?
Who gets the most phone training?
Answer: the salesperson

Who has the most sales opportunities per day?
Who has the greatest impact on owner retention?
Answer: the service advisor

That’s why it is good business to train your service advisors to generate increased profits for you.

Make a Profitable Decision
Would it be worth your while to train your salespeople to sell an additional 200 new units per year? I certainly hope so! Would it then make sense to train your writers how to become advisors?

As you can see by my example, a salesperson must sell about 23 cars a month to equal the gross profit performance of a service advisor writing 15 repair orders a day at 1.5 hours per RO. Now do the math and you will instantly realize the additional profit potential for this advisor without writing any additional repair orders. For example, 2.2 hours per RO will generate about $60,000 in gross profit and 3.0 hours per RO will produce about $80,000.

Your “top gun” on your showroom floor would have to deliver about 44 cars a month to match the performance of this advisor! Remember, a service advisor should be a salesperson, not a clerk; thereby, enabling your dealership to achieve 100-percent service absorption.

As a dealer or general manager you should visit with your advisors daily, let them know you care, acknowledge a good job, correct substandard performance immediately and edify these advisors to their customers, their managers and their fellow employees.

The results will astound you.

You May Also Like

The New Rule of Fixed Ops

If you’re looking to improve the efficiency of your dealership, you must leverage your fixed operations in new ways.

How ready are you for the dominion of fixed ops as the savior of automotive retail?

Some will argue that it has always held this coveted position but is rarely acknowledged to have this power. The spotlight has always been on new cars and variable operations, but with the pandemic, fixed ops’ prestige has enjoyed a remarkable uplift. This rise of stardom will accelerate in 2023 and beyond. 

Servicing Mercedes-Benz AMG Braking Systems

There are three different braking systems that are being used on late-model Mercedes-Benz AMG vehicles.

Organize Your Heart Out with Snap-on Magnetic Tool Holders

Technicians who love an organized workspace will fall for the new flexible magnetic tool holders from Snap-on.

Myers Tire Supply Announces New TPMS Programming App

The new app provides rapid programming in one tap, and it won’t disturb other sensors while programming.

Myers-branded TPMS programming app for the U-Pro Hybrid NFC sensor.

This diagnostic tool is capable of scanning passenger cars, heavy-duty vehicles, motorcycles, ATVs/UTVs, boats and more.


Other Posts

NADA 2023: DealerPRO Training – Magic Show

Learn about the magic of joining forces with an award-winning leader in fixed stops training.

NGK/NTK, Autel Collaborate on Webinar Series

The series consists of six 60-minute webinars that dig deep into system diagnostics of domestic and import vehicle models.

Top 3 Ways to Attract Skilled Workers During a Talent Shortage

Today’s companies need a game-changing way to recruit and deliver value to their greatest asset — skilled workers.

BendPak Launches EV & Powertrain Lifting Systems

Mobi-EVS full-rise, battery-powered, mobile scissor lift tables are designed for removing and installing high-voltage battery packs.