Negative Equity - AutoSuccessOnline

Negative Equity

The number of dealer-arranged finance transactions with negative equity is increasing, as is their dollar amount.

Short-Term Elation, Long-Term Consternation

Hedonism with 22-in. wheels and a 10-speed transmission, funded by a120-month installment sale agreement with $6,500 in negative equity.

We’re actively engaged in the business of selling new or newer cars and light trucks to eager buyers open to creative ways to pay for them. If we want to stay in business, that’s what we do.  

In this era of computer-designed and robot-assembled vehicles, Americans are keeping their cars longer. R.L. Polk says new vehicle owners keep their cars for around six years. The average age of the modern vehicle fleet is 11.4 years.  

Extended-term financing has kept monthly payments manageable. Credit Karma data for the first quarter of 2019 recorded an average new vehicle monthly payment of $554, with $391 monthly for used vehicles. The average repayment term for new vehicles was 69 months. The average monthly lease payment was $457. 

At the onset of 2020, optimism is running high in the best-of-all-possible-worlds Trump economy at a time when selections of new or pre-owned vehicles appear to be the most alluring. As a result, the number of dealer-arranged finance transactions with negative equity is increasing, as is their dollar amount. In some instances, a portion of the negative equity on an earlier transaction finds its way into the latest installment sale agreement. 

The ready remedy is longer-term car financing, up to 120 months — just 60 months shy of a 15-year home mortgage. Now, the vehicle owner is in the untenable position of effectively being out of the new or pre-owned car market for a minimum of 96 to 108 months. Needless to say, the owner of a car financed for 10 years needs to have the oil changed at regular intervals because he is stuck with that vehicle for a very long time.

For those of us who sell cars for a living, we’ve taken this prospective buyer out of at least one trade cycle. And that’s likely the good news. When the regulators figure this out, they’ll probably set limits on how much negative equity can be rolled forward into new deals. Unfortunately, the consumer advocates will somehow hold us accountable for finance charges on par with the selling price of the car.

Granted, caveat emptor prevails. That said, we need to be doubly certain that we’ve clearly identified and properly recited the mandated TILA-box disclosures on big dollar negative equity transactions.

You May Also Like

Say Yes to the Plan, or Plan to Fail

The most successful dealers are partnering with specialized companies, and this doesn’t have to take as much of your time as you think. 

In 2020, the world and the car business got turned upside down. In 2021, the landscape changed again as we dealt with too much inventory at the beginning of the year and not enough by the end. Then 2022 was one big inventory shortage, and while most of the year was easy profit, we forgot how to sell cars. 

You Aren’t Doing Enough to Prevent Fraud

Dealers need to implement what’s now considered everyday technology that can help them spot synthetic identity fraud before it happens.

Top Tips for 2023

F&I managers should familiarize themselves with vehicle options so they can effectively justify products based on its features.

How Understanding Consumers Can Help Mitigate F&I Losses

A change in mindset and philosophy will best serve those dealerships that embrace a more modern way of retailing.

Taking Control of Financing

It is in the dealership’s best interest to be proactive in addressing the customer’s understanding of auto loans and savings, and to clarify the benefits of financing through the dealership.

Other Posts

All the Buzz from Texas

Another NADA show is in the books and, like most of the people I spoke with, I’m energized about what I saw for the future of our industry.

3 Ways Conversational AI Yields More Satisfied Employees

Implementing conversational AI software in your store — in sales or service — is truly putting your employees first.

Take Control of Your Lead Management & Follow Up

Learn how Mac Haik Chevrolet has taken control of lead management and follow up, greatly improving their business.

Go Home Google, You’re Drunk!

If a dealership sends mixed signals to Google, the negative impact on the dealer’s bottom line could be monumental.