Keys to a Higher Car Count - AutoSuccessOnline

Keys to a Higher Car Count

Sustainable tactics to increase your numbers.

Car count has been a concern of just about every dealership at one point or another.

While it may seem the responsibility of the owner or manager, the truth is, that improving your car count is an entire department effort and can’t be done without everyone on staff buying in and pulling their weight.

Establishing a dynamic shop culture with an all-for-one, one-for-all spirit, while also being smart with your marketing, are the two keys to getting your car count to where you want it to be and keeping it there.

Teamwork Makes the Dream Work

Again, absolutely everyone in your shop needs to take responsibility for car count for the business to succeed.

Techs need to produce quality work that leads to satisfied customers who will return to your shop and refer their friends. They also need to be presentable, act professional and represent your shop well, even if they don’t interact with customers face-to-face.

Whoever works your front counter, be it a service advisor or another employee, needs to be courteous, presentable and knowledgeable. They need to not only have the right answers for questions customers have, but they also need to be able to ask the right questions to show your customers they know what they’re doing and are more than capable of taking good care of them.

In addition to your employees looking good, your waiting and reception areas need to be pristine as well. Are your restrooms clean? Is the front entrance covered in muddy footprints? These are the seemingly unimportant things that can ultimately mean the difference between having a car count that puts you in the black and one that leaves you in the red. It doesn’t matter whose responsibility these tasks are — it’s all hands on deck if you want to run a successful repair shop.

Once you have a solid cultural foundation in place at your shop, you can turn your attention to improving your car count. The first step isn’t getting more customers through your doors though — it’s focusing on keeping the customers that you already have. 

Retain, Retain, Retain!

A major reason for a struggling car count is customer attrition.

The term “attrition” is often misunderstood in our industry. Simply put, it’s the rate at which your shop loses customers — something that happens to every shop on the planet.

There are two types of attrition — controllable and uncontrollable.

Uncontrollable attrition involves factors beyond your control. If a customer passes away or moves to a different city, there’s nothing you can do.

But, when you lose customers due to your own negligence that falls into the controllable attrition category.

Controllable attrition includes losing customers as a result of poor service, bad communication, failing to meet expectations, loss of trust, lack of proper follow-up and having the perception of providing low value. It’s bad enough to lose a customer due to factors beyond your control, but when you start losing customers due to controllable attrition, you’ll be scrambling to maintain a viable car count.

A misdiagnosis — a prime example of controllable attrition — is the easiest way to lose customers and ruin relationships. Miscommunication is a close second, so having well-trained, well-spoken individuals on your front lines is absolutely imperative to building trust and developing good relationships with your customers. That’s because in addition to losing a customer due to negligence, you’re also most likely losing that customer’s friends, family members, social media followers, etc.

Bad word of mouth and bad online reviews are auto repair shop poison and the only real antidote is to avoid going down this path in the first place. It’s about 10 times more difficult (and costly) to keep an existing customer versus attracting a new one so try to remember that every time you interact with a good customer at your shop.

Educate, Empower & Engage

Fostering good, trusting relationships with your customers produces a sense of loyalty that will keep them coming back to your shop. Eventually, with enough good experiences, they’ll bring their vehicle to you without even thinking about it.

A simple follow-up phone call can be both informative and productive. You can enhance your client’s view of your shop since you’re making sure they got what they needed, while also learning about the customer experience your shop is providing.

It’s important for your customers to feel like they were treated with respect and their experience was a positive one. This can be tricky with major repairs as these are often costly, but your staff should most definitely be able to explain and educate vehicle owners as to exactly what needed to be done and why.

Most car owners will be understanding and appreciative of your efforts, even if presented with a large bill. Educating your customer as to why their vehicle needs a given repair will empower them to feel like they’re a part of the repair process, and this level of engagement will also foster a strong sense of loyalty that will keep your customer attrition rate low.

When you feel like you’re doing a good job of retaining your current customers, then (and only then) is it time to start attracting new ones.

Strategic Marketing

The first thing to keep in mind when you’re looking to attract new customers is to be mindful not to alienate your existing client base. Do not offer specials exclusively to new customers, as your regulars will tend to be upset by not being rewarded for their loyalty.

While increasing traffic in your shop is usually a signifier that business is doing well, be careful not to discount your services too much in your pursuit of more cars.

Coupons, bounceback offers, etc., can quickly turn even your best customers into vampires, sucking your business dry.

The biggest thing to remember about coupons is that, even if the margin is tiny, they must be profitable for your shop.

Don’t ever do anything — oil changes, tire rotations, etc. — for free. Odds are you’ll have a lot of people take advantage of this offer and you’ll never see them again.

A lot of small businesses fall into the trap of discounting their products/services so much that it becomes detrimental to their profitability and, ultimately, their ability to keep their doors open.

One major thing to avoid in the auto repair industry is offering a joint savings on parts and labor. Never do this. Pick one or the other — parts or labor. Doubling up can be a nightmare and dramatically affect your bottom line.

Another big thing to remember in terms of coupon distribution is to always specify that each offer is a one-off, good for one visit/one car only and can’t be combined with other offers. Coupon chasers will take advantage of any language they can and cost your shop both time and money if you let them.

Offer a premium experience that chain shops and such cannot provide – that’s your best way to maximize the ROI on your marketing efforts; not by giving away the house just to get people through the front door. 

Deliver on Your Promises

Once you have your message out in the community, you need to make sure your shop delivers when new customers come through the door. Your new clients must feel like what was promised to them in your marketing collateral has been delivered on, otherwise it’s very unlikely you’ll ever see them again.

Be sure to avoid ever promising something you can’t guarantee or sustain forever. Don’t promise things like the “fastest oil change in town,” since you might not be able to deliver on this once your shop sees an uptick in traffic. You also don’t want to promise the cheapest oil change (or the cheapest anything for that matter!) since it’s easy for your competitors to undercut you, even temporarily.

Your advertisements should be viewed as an opportunity to set yourself apart from the competition. Emphasize your shop’s commitment to customer satisfaction. Talk about treating your clients like family. Showcase your passion for auto repair, your unwavering love for your community and your dedication to be the very best shop in your market. Then, deliver on those sentiments!

Remember, your customers are the lifeblood of your business, which is why treating them with respect, going above and beyond, and communicating properly are so important.

Honesty and integrity are valuable (and increasingly rare) commodities in this world, so being able to show that your shop does business in an ethical manner, delivers on promises and makes sure its customers have the best possible experience will go a long way toward helping your bottom line.

We’ve all lost sleep worrying about car count, but if you can instill a sense of togetherness amongst your staff, treat your customers right and market your shop effectively, you’ll definitely sleep better at night!

For online bio:

David Rogers is chief operating officer of Keller Bros. Inc., president of Auto Profit Masters and president of Shop 4D, an Artificial Intelligence (AI)-enabled, self-learning system for proactively managing repairs, customers, marketing, profits and employees. Reach David via email at [email protected], toll-free at 1-866-826-7911, or online at

You May Also Like

USO, UTI Partner to Support Service Members’ Career Transitions

A highlight of the collaboration includes networking support with industry leaders to help facilitate training and job placement.

USO, UTI Partner to Support Service Members' Career Transitions

United Service Organizations (USO) and Universal Technical Institute (UTI) have announced a partnership to support military service members with their transition to civilian life. The collaboration will focus on offering specialized training programs and resources for careers in the transportation, skilled trades and energy industries, the organizations reported in a press release.

Why Do Vehicles Go Out of Alignment?

If camber, caster or toe are out of specifications, there is usually a reason why.

Hunter Engineering: ADAS Calibration & Connectivity Drive Growth

Hunter’s Pete Liebetreu explains the company’s Ultimate ADAS system, its areas of growth and its outlook on wheel service for EVs.

Hunter's Pete Liebetreu explains the company's Ultimate ADAS system, its areas of growth and its outlook on wheel service for EVs.
Selecting the Ideal Car Lift for EV Servicing

When choosing the right car lift for servicing electric vehicles there are several key factors to consider.

Key Factors in Selecting the Ideal Car Lift for Electric Vehicle Servicing- Coats
Mayhew Introduces 14-Piece Micro Hand Tool Set

This new set is a compilation of all the current micro line products, including pry bars, picks, hooks and screwdrivers.

This new set is a compilation of all the current micro line products from Mayhew; including pry bars, picks, hooks and screwdrivers.

Other Posts

BendPak Offers Space-Saving Full-Rise Scissor Lift

The new BendPak SP-7XE Series of full-rise scissor lifts provides the performance and undercarriage access of traditional two-post lifts in a more compact, space-saving package.

The new BendPak SP-7XE Series of full-rise scissor lifts provides the performance and undercarriage access of traditional two-post lifts in a more compact, space-saving package. Floor- and flush-mount models of this frame-engaging lift are available.
Hunter Engineering Wins Optimizely Award

Hunter employed several Optimizely products to help provide exceptional customer experiences. With the assistance of Optimizely CMS, Hunter’s corporate website saw a 70% increase in monthly average pageviews.

Hunter Engineering Wins Optimizely Award
Collision Careers Launches Digital Campaign to Attract Technicians

Aimed at attracting technicians to the field, the videos highlight various professional roles in collision repair including structural technicians, estimators and electric diagnostics technicians.

collision careers tech shortage
ASE, Dealer Associations Partner to Increase Awareness of Automotive Careers

ASE is partnering with dealer associations to conduct student competitions designed to increase awareness of automotive career opportunities.

young automotive technicians and mechanics