Employment Screening and Credit Reports - AutoSuccessOnline

Employment Screening and Credit Reports

Pulling credit reports on a customer makes sense when determining the credit worthiness of a person who may be financing a car or other item. However, pulling a credit report based upon a person seeking employment with a company is a whole different matter.

Pulling credit reports on a customer makes sense when determining the credit worthiness of a person who may be financing a car or other item. However, pulling a credit report based upon a person seeking employment with a company is a whole different matter. Employers should be very wary of pulling credit reports on an applicant for employment purposes and using said reports to make a hiring decision unless the position oversees, handles or manages money.

When the financial markets crashed in 2008, commonly referred to as the Great Recession, millions of hardworking and responsible people lost their jobs, their homes and their dignity. Home valuations were bloated; people were provided credit with little to no financial backing or collateral, resulting in John Q. Citizen becoming overleveraged. When the crash occurred, inflated home values plummeted, hard-working people could not pay their mortgages, some had their homes foreclosed or were forced to sell their homes for less than the mortgage owed. 

As a result, many people took a financial hit, which was reflected on their credit reports. It has taken years for most people to recover from that experience and some residual of that period of time can still be seen on people’s credit. Therefore, generally speaking, pulling an applicant’s credit as part of the background screening process usually will not assist the employer with making an informed hiring

decision. A blemish on a person’s credit report is not indicative of a person’s work capabilities and ethic.

Employers should only pull a credit report on an applicant if the position’s responsibilities include overseeing, handling or managing money. When pulling a credit report on an applicant, the reasons for the pull should be related to the job they are being hired for and for business necessity. 

For example, a car detailer at a dealership will not handle or manage money, therefore there is no job relatedness or business necessity

to review the applicant’s credit history. Conversely, a position that requires a person to oversee or manage money satisfies the job-related criteria for having credit pulled on the applicant. Similarly, business necessity and job relatedness would suggest a credit report be pulled on an applicant who is applying for the comptroller position for a car dealership.

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) has spoken out against running credit reports on employment applicants as a general course of conducting background checks. The EEOC has suggested such a practice might be discriminatory against minorities and women, unless the position has a business necessity and job relatedness requirement to do as such. 

Overall, there are many components to hiring applicants for your company, one such component involves conducting background checks. As a rule, pulling a credit report

on all employment applicants may not be appropriate, particularly if the position does not oversee, handle or manage money. Understanding a person’s credit history if they have the responsibility of managing or handling money is the correct utilization of credit reports in the hiring process.

The author of this article is not an attorney and offers no legal advice. The contents of this article should be reviewed by your corporate attorney before taking any action based on its content. 

Click here to view more solutions from Andrew Scott and Scott-Roberts & Associates, LLC.

You May Also Like

Identifying Gaps in Digital Retailing Solutions & 5 Easy Fixes

Inconsistencies slow the purchase process, erode consumer trust and eliminate the willingness to purchase.

Identifying Gaps in Digital Retailing Solutions & 5 Easy Fixes

I was recently talking with my friend and industry expert Brian Pasch about the automotive industry and its many growing pains. We discussed how the market continues to evolve and push further into a digital retailing-first approach, despite many dealerships simply not being ready for the change.

The adoption of digital tools has certainly brought about numerous benefits — including a more data-driven approach to turning leads into sales — but it has also exposed certain gaps that need to be addressed. Among the most glaring issues are the lack of personalization and consistency across digital retailing solutions. In this article, we’ll explore these gaps and discuss why they are crucial to the success of car dealerships in the digital age.

Don’t Be ‘Nice’ to Your Team — Be Caring

Here are four steps to take to lead a team that minimizes critical actions and will put our team members on the path to success.

team leadership
The Top 3 Reasons You’re Missing on Used Vehicles

As front-end profits tighten, misses on used vehicles hurt more. To tighten up acquisition and pricing, you need a different way of operating.

The Top 3 Reasons You’re Missing on Used Vehicles - AutoVision
Everyday Actions, Monumental Outcomes

It is in the quiet moments of consistent work that our skills are sharpened and our goals are realized.

True success is the product of a daily grind, forged from focus, dedication and perseverance.
Celebrating a Year’s Worth of Automotive Industry Standouts

As we bid farewell to this year, let’s extend another heartfelt shout-out to each of our remarkable 2023 honorees.

Celebrating a Year’s Worth of Automotive Industry Standouts

Other Posts

The SMS Paradigm: Reshaping Customer Engagement in the Automotive Industry

By reaching out through SMS, we have tapped into the potential of a less invasive, yet highly effective, method of communication.

The SMS Paradigm: Reshaping Customer Engagement in the Automotive Industry
Is a Vehicle Test Drive Still Relevant Today?

An important part of the process, the test drive is the strongest opportunity to build the customer’s positive emotions around the vehicle.

Is a Vehicle Test Drive Still Relevant Today?
Is Marketing Both the Problem and Solution for the EV Market?

Marketing can answer consumers’ questions and demystify the EV buying journey.

Is Marketing Both the Problem and Solution for the EV Market? myAutoIQ article
Closing the Appraisal Gap

A new OBD II enriched with VIN-centric reconditioning cost data, not estimates, is now integrated into workflow software to eliminate intentionally overlooked or ignored yet authentic reconditioning exposure at appraisal.

Closing the Appraisal Gap - Rapid Recon