The Ultimate Best Practices for Internet Lead Follow-Up

The Ultimate Best Practices for Internet Lead Follow-Up

A successful dealer knows that every lead needs to be contacted quickly and effectively in order to close them at or above industry benchmark.


By Matt Like, e-commerce director for Morgan Auto Group

The internet has changed how people buy cars. A lot of people do research online and then go to the dealership to test drive their favorite model. Some people are ready to buy right away, but others want to get more information before making a decision. That’s where you come in — you’re the trusted advisor who helps customers through this buying process. But if you don’t follow up with your leads, they might never end up buying a car from you!

In this article, we’ll explain why it’s important for dealerships to implement the best practices for following up with internet leads, then dive into what those best practices look like.

Dealerships get hundreds or thousands of internet leads per month. A successful dealer knows that every lead needs to be contacted quickly and effectively in order to close them at or above industry benchmark.

Let’s take a look at some common pitfalls to avoid that prevent dealers from maximizing their performance with internet leads:

  • Failure to read and comprehend the lead
  • Only calling one time
  • Following up too slowly (longer than five minutes)
  • Sending generic CRM email templates
  • Failure to engage the customer with SMS text
  • Failure to address direct or implied questions in the lead comments
  • Failure to get manager involvement after two-way communication has been established
  • Failure to track lead-to-appointment, appointment show and show-to-close percentages

Now that we know what “not to do,” let’s explore the best practices that have helped dealers achieve outstanding closing percentages with internet leads.

In order to run an internet department efficiently, there are a few simple metrics that dealerships should pay close attention to. According to Brian Pasch, an industry expert and consultant in automotive digital marketing, the “4 X 60 rule” should be applied to internet leads:

  • Lead to Contact – 60%
  • Contact to Appointment – 60%
  • Appointment Show – 60%
  • Show to Close – 60%

Using the 4 X 60 rule, we calculate that 100 internet leads should produce 60 two-way conversations, 36 appointments, 22 shown appointments and 13 sales. If your CRM doesn’t track lead contact, you can always calculate your lead-to-appointment by skipping lead contact and aim for a 36% appointment rate. 

There are many CRM workflow processes one can follow with great results, but we’ve found that the “email sandwich” method tends to work the best:

Day 1

  1. Immediate Phone Call (with voicemail)
  2. Send Personalized Email (with personalized video)
  3. Send SMS Text (follow TCPA regulations) with video
  4. Second Phone Call (after 5 p.m., no voicemail)

Days 2-5

  1. Morning Call and Voicemail (before 9 a.m.)
  2. Personalized Email
  3. Evening Call – No Voicemail (after 5 p.m.)

Week 2 to 6 months

  1. Automatic CRM emails every two weeks
  2. Phone Call (twice a week up to month 2)

Following this process means 10 phone calls and five emails over five days, before placing the customer into long term follow-up with automatic marketing emails for six months. The first week of follow-up is where 80% of the appointments will be made. Many dealers give up too soon and don’t provide high-value communication, which is why so many fail to capture the car deal. 

It’s vital to nail the process on day one with high-quality follow-up. On day one, response time and communication quality will train the customer on what to do with all subsequent follow-up attempts. You only get one chance to make a stellar impression, and that’s what it takes to win the business! A good rule of thumb is to ensure that every contact attempt adds value and is worth the customer’s time and limited attention span.

PRO-TIP: The initial goal of lead follow-up should be to establish a connection and build a relationship. Don’t add pressure by asking for the appointment before earning the right to do so.

Following these practices will develop effective follow-up habits and secure more sales!

You May Also Like

How AI is Enhancing Vehicle Inspections for Car Buying, Selling and Transportation

AI offers three distinct advantages for vehicle inspections that can significantly increase efficiency and bolster confidence for the industry.

AI vehicle inspection, artificial intelligence

By Vlad Kadurin, product and operations lead at Ship.Cars

Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming nearly every industry, and the automotive sales, remarketing and transportation sector is no different. AI-powered vehicle inspections have recently emerged as a groundbreaking innovation.

Vehicle inspections are crucial to determining a car's condition and value, facilitating informed decisions for both buyers and sellers. In an industry that is increasingly buying, selling and trading vehicles virtually and transporting them long distances, AI is quickly becoming an indispensable tool.

Navigating Tomorrow’s Roads: 5 Trends Shaping the Future of Commercial Automotive in 2024

Dealerships who offer dedicated commercial service bays or who provide mobile service offerings enhance their value.

Work Truck Solutions blog - ebike delivery in city
The Dealership Flywheel: A Perspective from X-Amazonian

Customer obsession is key. Every dealership must have processes in place to never fail a customer.

service customer and mechanic
New Research Reveals Age and Gender Differences in Vehicle Add-On Purchases

Are there certain age/gender demographics with a higher propensity of purchasing any specific set of VPPs? This study sheds light on consumer preferences and priorities when it comes to safeguarding and maintaining vehicles.

study about age and gender differences - man and woman
How Generative AI Is Impacting Auto Lending Compliance

What is often left out of recent headlines, is the extraordinary power of AI to reduce harm, including fair lending and discrimination risks.

Other Posts

How AI and Automation Revolutionizes Dealer Sales Operations

Powering sales operations with AI and automation gives dealers an outsized advantage in their market, getting sales from shoppers they never thought possible.

5 Predictions for Front-Line Chat Solutions

In the next few years, prepare for a chat solution that must act like a personal greeter to every customer who visits your digital showroom.

Maximizing Fleet Uptime: A Dealer’s Guide

This guide provides actionable insights for dealers to ensure their fleets are always on the move.

Your Service Department’s Undervalued Opportunity: Streamlining RO Stories

Consider how much time repair event stories take to write. Now, multiply that by the number of technicians employed at your dealership and you could easily be wasting hundreds of technician hours every month.